Can kidney stones cause kidney disease or kidney failure?

I covered the short-term symptoms and consequences of kidney stones in my previous post. Let's talk a little about the long term consequences. A question that is often asked is whether kidney stones can lead to progressive kidney disease/kidney failure. This is not an easy question to answer; in fact it should probably be rephrased to say, "can kidney stones be associated with kidney disease/failure?" This is because current medical studies that have addressed this issue have proven association, and not causation. At least, not yet!

Researchers studied this issue in patients who were diagnosed with kidney stones in Minnesota, US, between 1986 to 2003, and followed patients for an average of about 8 years to see if they developed kidney disease (CKD), or kidney failure (ESRD). Their study revealed that people with kidney stones could be at a higher risk of developing CKD, but not ESRD.  However, more recently, another study addressing this question was published in the British Medical Journal in August 2012. The results of this study showed that patients who developed even one kidney stone were significantly more likely to develop both CKD, and ESRD (over 11 years of follow up). Before you panic on reading this, let me say that the results do remind me of a quote variously attributed to Mark Twain and Benjamin Disraeli (among others): "there are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics"! Without taking away anything from the researchers/statisticians of this second study, the results clearly showed that even though the risk was higher, in real terms, the absolute risk still remained pretty low (2.4 per million person-days in people with stones). 

So what does this mean for you? If you have a kidney stone, you could have a very slightly higher chance of developing kidney disease/failure than the average Joe. In other words, the overwhelming majority of patients with kidney stones will not see themselves advancing to kidney failure. 

How kidney stones cause chronic kidney disease (if at all) is a question that still needs further research. Current hypothetical explanation include calcification of the kidneys' interstitial tissue, scarring, urinary tract obstruction, side effects of interventions like lithotripsy that are done to treat stones, etc. As I mentioned above, the relationship between kidney disease and stones might just be an association, wherein a third factor is causing both these entities to appear! 

Comments

  1. AnonymousDecember 20, 2014 at 5:58 PM

    Dr. Michael Traver of Western Michigan Urological Associates discusses kidney stones, symptoms, evaluation and treatment.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I do not want dialysis: how long can I expect to live, and how would I feel?

Image
I often see patients in my office who refuse dialysis (should it become necessary) for their advancing kidney disease. I divide these patients in to two categories. The more common category is patients who refuse it because of the "fear of dialysis". They could have trouble understanding dialysis and what potential benefits they could derive from it. They would often make good dialysis candidates who have more to lose than gain by refusing dialysis therapies. The other category is the patient who rightfully refuses dialysis because she or he would not make a good candidate for such treatment. There could be multiple reasons for that. It could be advanced age and frailty, presence of other severe disease conditions like heart failure or metastatic cancer, etc. In such cases, it is hard to always predict if dialysis would add anything to the quality/quantity of life. And often, patients are simply looking at the "big picture". So the questions that come up in
Read more

Is a vegan or vegetarian diet better for patients with kidney disease?

Image
Over the last few decades, we have seen the accumulation of evidence that supports the health benefits of plant-based diets. Vegetarian diets have been shown to be associated with a lower incidence of obesity, hypertension ,  diabetes , and coronary artery disease . Since all these entities are risk factors for chronic kidney disease (CKD), it might be reasonable to assume that these diets might actively reduce the risk of CKD development and progression. However, at the very outset, let me emphasize that any diet, vegetarian or not, comes with the same restrictions that are advised for patients with CKD . For instance, potassium intake might need to be restricted in advanced CKD. Fruits, a significant portion of the vegetarian diet, are an important source of potassium, and will need to be appropriately restricted. So you have to watch what you eat regardless. More importantly, you owe it to yourself to know what exactly is there in the food that you eat.
Read more